Brian, your essays are dreamlike, your thoughts are long and deep.
And yes, we must choose the third way.
Part Two of this essay is now published. Enjoy!
“Real humility creates openings; the false type shuts them down. If prophesy does depend on our ability to see clearly into the moment, whatever this moment might be—to boldly recognize patterns that are just beginning to emerge or to probe into patterns that have long been in existence, but which, for whatever reason, have not yet become visible—then our success may come more from a set of classical virtues than from a bag of occult powers. We have only to differentiate real virtues from their substitutes.”
Here’s the heart of one of the oldest human dilmmas. That “only” makes me smile. Only. We only have to become capable of discerning true virtue from artificial virtue. This one of the branches of learning the great patterns of life and the cosmos, of wisdom and of love.
Why am I replying to you, Marco? Because when I go to the published essay page, it has no invitation to join the discussion, like it always has before.
That invitation should be there now, Maía, if you reload your page. It did not display at first because of a glitch.
Hi Maia,
Sorry to take so long getting back to you. I hadn’t noticed the comment. You write,
“Here’s the heart of one of the oldest human dilemmas. That “only” makes me smile. Only. We only have to become capable of discerning true virtue from artificial virtue.”
Good catch! The “only” here is meant to complicate matters exactly in the way you describe. This essay has a long history. From 2008 to 2013, I was one of the Boston organizers for the Evolver movement. This was a movement founded by Daniel Pinchbeck that was organized about the planting of local “spores,” where largescale issues related to the transformation of consciousness could be addressed on a local scale. The focus of the movement was broad—way too broad!—ranging from contemporary shamanism, ancient mythology and cosmology, urban gardening, gift economies, UFOs, alternate dimensions, polyamory, brainwave technology, and entheogens. The Snare of Distance grew out of a series of notes I took at a 2012 Evolver discussion on what a “Psychedelic Ethics” might look like.
As is often the case with such discussions, many fertile ideas were bounced around without the issue becoming clearer at the end of four enjoyable hours. I saw this as both a problem and a challenge. On the simplest level, I’m often skeptical about the usefulness of any abstract concept of “ethics,” as in “corporate ethics” or the ethics that bind lawyers to acting in a particular manner for their clients. A lawyer may act in a way that’s technically ethical, while their actions protect and enable a client whose policies are borderline-criminal and may have devastating effects on society and the planet.
So, I was certainly curious, on both a practical and aesthetic level, as to what a “Psychedelic Ethics” might look like. There was a general sense among the group—one common since the 1960s—that entheogens of various types were associated in some general way with enlightenment, that they removed psychic obstructions, prompted healing, and opened the gates of perception. By becoming more attuned to the secret order of the cosmos, the voyager would then be better empowered to set an example and act as an agent for social, even global, change.
Three years after this, I wrote the first version of The Snare of Distance. Between the time the discussion took place and the time I wrote this essay, general faith in the idea of a contagious global transformation of consciousness and/or the possibility of an apocalypse had fizzled out. While I do tend to view human history in terms of the unfolding of vast cycles, and while the Mayan calendar may have pointed to a period that may even now be unfolding, I have never seen the point to putting any faith in dates, except in the most approximate manner.
So, even in writing the first version of this essay, I tried to keep just about all of my arguments and Anamnesian Virtues and Maxims pretty ambiguous. And since this first version of the essay was published in Metapsychosis in 2016, something like the exact opposite of enlightened consciousness seems to have spread like a contagion across the globe. Curiously, too, entheogens have since been heavily corporatized, with a steady rightward drift and much oligarchic backing. Who would have suspected that Elon Musk would turn into a prophet?
In retrospect, it does seem as though entheogens act more as all-purpose catalysts rather than specifically as agents of enlightenment—Manson and his followers took plenty of LSD—and that specific ethical concepts are somewhat less important than who happens to believe them and how they translate these concepts into action.
In this essay and in most of my work, even where I use the most direct language, I tend to write so that a statement can be read in multiple ways. One of my favorite prophetic statements is the famous one by the Oracle of Delphi, that “If King Croesus crosses the Halys River, a great empire will be destroyed.” Croesus took this to mean that he would defeat the Persians. The opposite happened.
Anamnesian Virtue number1: Detachment: the capacity to see the ocean that will swallow up all things, and to listen as it whispers in your ear. You should, paradoxically, become even more empathic as the degree of your detachment grows. You may act on this, or not. You may spill your blood as a purely symbolic gesture, in service to those humans yet unborn. You may feel the pain of the multitudes that you kill.
Anamnesian Maxim number #: We must learn how to accept the full responsibility for our actions, and be the first to gladly admit it when we are wrong. If we discover, as in a dream, that we have caused harm to the innocent, we must accuse those who have dared to point their fingers at us, for it is they who have tainted our otherwise spotless minds.
Just to let you know, Brian, I tried to comment on your idea that
entheogens are catalysts, and don’t directly cause certain types of
experiences connected with enlightment, psychosis, etc.
BUT I kept getting a message from the website that my comment was
“blank” and thus I could not post it!
Maybe I’ll try again later…